Telegraph secrecy system



@ec- 9, 1947. I Y W, H, Buss 2,432,188

' TELEGRAPH SECRECY SYSTEM Filddune 22, 1944v 4 sheets-sheet 1 RAD l G TELEGRAPH TRANSMITTER ATTORNEY 4 Sheets-Sheet 2 w. H. BLISS Y TELEGRAPH SECRECY SYSTEM Filed June '22, 1944 IVV'IIIII AIAIAAIAA b. l MWIIIil-lw l. N INVENTOR WARREN H. BLISS.

Illu" xmououmd Decfe, 1947.

.N .mmh

ATTRN'EY Dec. 9, 1947. W. H. BLISS TELEGRAPH sEcREcY SYSTEM 4 Sheets-Sheet 3 Filed June 22, 1944 @o una 29E .5950

@T mmDF PPPPEQI VTC l1 C?. Elx.

lNvNToR WARREN H. BL\5S.

BY` I@ .Y .www

ATTORNEY W. H. BLISS TELGRAPH SEGRECY SYSTEM Dec. 9, 1947.

Filed June 22, 1944 4 Sheets-Sheet 4 Fij.'5.

' ATTORNEY Patented Dec. 9, 194'?v UN iTED ES PATE NT' O F I C E.

TELE GRAPHr SECRECYQSYSTEM Warren H.- Bliss,` Riverhead; N YL, assgnorl to Radio Corporation of America, a corporationroffl Delaware Application Jne 22, 1944,V Serial No. 541,569

(Cl. 17d-22) 11 Claims.

This invention relates to secrecy systems for'th'eA transmission and' receptionv of intelligencev by wire or radio channels. The fundamental'principle involvedisthat certain portions ofstandard telegraph dots anddashes may be deleted prior to transmission and automatically replaced at the receiving terminal. By* this system the character of the material transmitted'by Wire or. radio appears erratic and'unintelligible, but `may be readily translated into intelligence atanV authorized;

receiving station by means of'suitable equipment when properly synchronized.

Itis an object of my invention to provideequipment for scrambling and unscrambling convene tional telegraph code signals'in such manner thatV the-signals as transmitted would berendered unintelligibleand when properly translated at an authorized receiving station shall be rendered en.

tirely intelligible;

Among the advantages of this system, it will be noted-that" it' does not involveA complicatedr Fig. 2 shows a circuit diagram of apparatus to. be used at an authorized receiving ,station for re ception of the signalsand for unscrambling the same;

Fig. 3 shows a plurality of graphs of signal wave forms delineated on a time scale, whereby the original code signals may be compared with the scrambled signals and with wave forms generated at the receiving station for unscrambling; and

Figs. 4, 5, and 6 illustrate respectively each of three alternative embodiments of the invention.

Fig. 1 shows the sending end'equipment for asystem using radio transmission. Unit 2 is, a standard auto headfor producing telegraph characters from perforated tape. synchronous motor from aGO-Cycle supply.v The output of this auto head is fed into a resistor IG.

latedandone conducting segment as shown, whileV Itis driven by a..

wheel has six insulated and sixV conductingseg-V ments. Each wheel has allfits segments of equal length. For completing the circuits through these wheelsrthe shaftof'each is electrically connected to the plusvvterminal ofzbattery 8 Whose minus tere minal-'is grounded.' The brush 5 of wheel 4 and 4brush 'l ofwheel l are connected' to resistor IIA andthe second 'cathode of diode l2.

Thevanodes of diode l2'arefconnected to ground' through series resistor` I5 and battery I6 as shown. The upper end. of `resistor l5 isconnected to av tone keyer Il' which is a conventional deviceffor, convertingA direct current pulses havingV mark (or space.)` significancerinto keyed tone signalS... Item I8' is a conventional radio telegraph transmitter Which radiates energy from antenna i9;

Ati-the receiving terminal, Eig.v 2', the signals are pickedup byl means ofjantenna 20and radio receiver 2l. The output-ofthe receiver taken as positive M l'. from its detector is fed through abiasing battery 2 2 to the control gridrcf a cathodeoutputtriode 232 The anode of triode 23 is directly, connected to the positive plate supply while, the 4output from cathode resistor 24 is con nectedj to the cathode of a signal limiter diode 25.V The anode of thisdiode is connected through resistor ZGQandbattery 2l to ground, as shown.

Triodes'L-andcomprise a flip-flop circuit having afsingle condition of stability. There are individual anode resistors 3land 33'and a common cathode resistor 38. The control grid of triode 30 isfed through condenser 28from the anode ofldi'ode 2,5 and is also connected to the anode of, tube 35 through resistor 32` and to ground through resistor 2B. There is also a con, denser 3 6'linking the anode ofv triode 30 to the control'grid of triode 35; A resistor 3l connects from .the cathodes of the two triodes to the control grid of tube 35.

Thecoutput ofthe above ip-op circuitis connected through condenser 34 and resistor "l0 to ilywheel oscillator 4B.. This oscillator circuit is preferably thesame as that described in United States Patent No. 2,274,841, issued toR. E. Mathes andV W; H: Bliss, referring to Fig. 4 therein. Hence, it requires `no detailed description herein. The output of this oscillator is'supplied through a phase'displacing circuit composed of inductance 41 and resistor 42 to the control grid of a gas tetrode 45;

Gas tetrodes` 45 and 5l are the essentialparts of aV second"flip'flop circuit; There are anode resistors 43 and 53 with a cross-connecting com- `mutatinggcondenser 44.` The cathode of tube 45 is connected to ground through resistor 46 and condenser 4l in parallel and the screen grid is connected through resistor 48 and battery 49 in series to ground. This screen grid of tetrode 45 also receives the incoming signal pulses from the anode of diode 25 through condenser 35. The control grid of tetrode 5I is connected to ground through resistor 56 and to the anode of tube 45 through condenser 52. The cathode and screen grid of tube 5I are connected directly to ground.

A combining dual diode tube 55 has one anode connected to the anode of diode 25 and its other anode to the cathode of tetrode 45. The cathodes of diode 55 are both connected to the cathode of diode 56 and to ground through a resistor 54. The anode of diode 56 is connected to a telegraph signal recorder 59 and to ground through series resistor 5l and battery 58. The telegraph recorder 59 may be of the conventional ink slip type frequently used in the art.

Operation Graph 6I is the brush output waveform of E. M. F. of brush 1, wheel 6, and while graph 62 is the output of brush 5, wheel 4. It is essential that the Wheels 4 and 6 and auto head 2 be so synchronized and phased that the outputs have relationships as shown by graphs B0, 6I, and 62. It is also necessary that the length of each segment on wheel 4 be an integral multiple of the unit length of the signals shown in graph 60. The length of two successive segments on wheel 6 must also be equal to or an integral submultiple of the signal baud. The combination of the outputs of brushes 5 and "I, produced by their parallel connection, is illustrated by graph 63.

Double diode I2 acts in a very special way to combine the auto head output, graph 60, and the composite brush output, graph 63, Resistor I5 must be several times as large as resistors I5 and II. With no output from the auto head 2 or brushes 5 and l, the potential of point 'II is nearly that of ground potential, there being a small voltage drop through the normally conducting diode l2 and resistors IU and I I. When a positive voltage from only one of the inputs (auto head or brushes) is applied to one of the cathodes of diode I2 this diode section cuts off and there is but a slight rise in potential at point 'II because of the low resistance path through the other conducting diode section. However, when positive voltages are applied simultaneously on the two cathodes of diode I2, conduction through both halves of the tube is blocked and point 'II will rise to and remain at the full potential of battery i6. It should be noted that the potentials of batteries 8 and 9 should be at least equal to that of battery I6.

For the example given in Fig, 3 of transmitting the letters BL the combined output as observed by the potential at point II is given by graph 64. This signal, which is similar to telegraph type material but which bears no apparent resemblance to the original message, is then used to key a conventional radio telegraph transmitter. The secrecy of this system lies in the fact that the transmitted signal has a scrambled appearance and is unlike the original code characters. A

close inspection of graphs 55 and 64 reveals that the secret message has been derived from the original by deleting certain small parts. These can be supplied again at the receiving terminal.

At the receiving terminal the detector output of the radio receiver 2|, Fig, 2, is passed through triode 23 biased beyond the cut-off point to produce a noise threshold control and also passed through a diode 25 which acts as a peak limiter. At point 'l2 the recovered signal is essentially the same as that of graph 64 which was transmitted.

This waveform is differentiated by condenser 28 and resistor 29 to give the trigger pulses shown by graph 65. These are applied to a flip-nop circuit composed of vacuum triodes 3i) and 35. Tube 35 is normally in a state of conduction and tube 30 in a state of non-conduction, and when one of the positive trigger pulses (graph 65) from the anode of dio-de 25 arrives at the control grid of triode 30, this tube is flipped into conduction for a short period of time. Because of the regenerative action between these two tubes, only one at a time is conducting while the other is biased to cut-oir. Since tube 35 has no stable or fixed negative bias it always resumes conduction soon after tube 30 is triggered. For the example shown, the conduction period for tube 30 should be about equal to one-half the unit length of the original signal.

Graph 66 shows the conduction vs. time relation of tube 30 as derived from the wave form of graph 55. Graph 66 also shows the voltage variation at the anode of triode 35 and is fed into oscillator 40 to synchronize it as described in United States Patent No. 2,274,841 (previously mentioned) The output of this oscillator is displaced in phase by inductance 4I and resistor 42 and its waveform as observed across resistor 42 is shown by graph 61.

Gas tetrodes 45 and 5I develop pulses to fill in those parts of the signal deleted at the sending end. The control grid of tetrode 45 receives the output from the oscillator (graph 61) and the screen grid of tetrode 45 has the incoming signal from diode 25 (graph 64) applied to it. Tube 5I is normally conducting and tube 45 normally non-conducting. Tube 45 is triggered every time its control grid and screen grid are simultaneously and momentarily made suiciently positive. A threshold line 'I3 is shown in connection with graph 61 to indicate on what part of the cycle tube 45 will iire, provided that an incoming signal potential is simultaneously applied to the screen grid.

Since tetrodes 45 and 5I are interconnected as a nip-nop circuit the conduction will always return back to tube 5I after an interval of time determined by the Values of condenser 52 and resistor 56. The conduction vs. time characteristic for tetrode 45 is shown as graph 68 and this is the output waveform of this tube as taken from its cathode.

Double diode 55 acts to combine the incoming signal from diode 25 (graph 64) and the filling in signal (graph 68) from tetrode 45. Inspection of graphs 64 and 68 show that at some instants both signals are positive simultaneously and so a diode limiter 56 is used to level oi the excess. The output voltage appears across resistor 57 and is identical with the original signal of graph 60. A telegraph recorder 59 may be used to register the received signal.

Fig. 4 illustrates a commutator wheel 95 which performs the combined functions of wheels 4 and 6 of Fig. 1. The output of this wheel 95, as picked up on brush 5, is as shown by graph 63, Fig. 3.

Fig. 5 illustrates an electronic system which performs the same function as commutator wheel 6. A condenser is slowly charged through series resistor I9 from the B+ plate supply. A gas triode 'I8 with series cathode resistors 8| and 83 periodically discharges this condenser 80 when .its -potential rrises t'o .a certain value. Cathode bypass condenser F82 lmaintains the .cathode 'at an `average positive potential which prevents Va con- Zti-nuousidischarge oficondenser 80.

Each time condenser 80 is .discharged a posi- ;tive pulse `will ybe developed across `resistor 8l. This pulse will be passed on through condenser SI! tothe control grid Vof gastriode 9 i In order to properly synchronize the :operation of fthe circuit Aof Fig. k5 with the standard auto head .2 .and 'commutator wheel 4 a (iO-cycle synchronizing voltage is fed into 'the .control grid of triode -i'lB throughcondensers l5 and 16. By adjustment 'of variable resistor 1.9 the :frequency and synchronism of the pulses developed at the .cathode of tube T8 are properlydetermined.

Gas A'triodes '9i and 92 `comprise a flip-nop circuit with tube .L32 being normally and stably conductive. Each pulse from triode 7S causes tube :91 to kbecome conductive for a short intervalof time but the state of conduction always returnsto tube S2. Because of the above explained action a waveform like that illustrated by graph 61, iFigLS, 'is developed at Vthe cathode of triode 9i. This output -may be used in place of the output from commutator wheel 6.

A circuit identical with that of Fig. 5 may also jbe fused in place tof commutator wheel 4. Inithis case drive motor 3 would not be needed.

Fig. 6 illustrates a modification ofthe receiving station equipment which takes the place of the arrangement shown in Fig. 2. The receiving stationhereshownuses vacuum tubes 05 and I @8 in :place of the gas tetrodes i5 and 5l of Fig. 2. The' oscillator unit 4S is the same in both embodiments. Other circuit components which are the same in Figs. 2 and 6 are given like reference numbers. Also for the sake of simplicity, certain portions of Fig. 2 are not shown in Fig.. 6, even though they may be essential to the operation of the alternative embodiment.

The output of oscillator @E causes triodes los and .H13 to be alternatively-conductive since this circuit is of the nip-flop type. The circuit connections for tubes IGS and Hi8 areconventional; including, as shown, anode resistors |02 and ID3, grid resistors H39 and H2, a cathode resistor i Il between ground 4and the cathode of tube tl, 'and resistors 04 -and lill for cross coupling between the anode of one tube and the grid of the other tube. The output of this flipilop circuit is taken fromthe cathode of tube H26 and is of the form shown by graph 6I, Fig. 3.

The operation of the circuit arrangement shown in Fig. 6 is further explained as follows: The incoming signal as shown by graph B4 in Fig. 3 develops anode potential Variations at point l2 of Fig. 6. These anode potential variations are passed directly to the left-hand cathode in the twin diode tube S6 and also through capacitor 28 to control tube 30 as previously explained. Ihe two diode sections of tube 96 in cooperation combine the incoming signal with the output from tube IE6 to produce a waveform represented by graph 14 in Fig. 3. This waveform is converted into the desired output Waveform shown by graph (i9 by means of a conventional locking circuit IDI, such, for eX- ample, as that shown in United States Patent No. 1,948,103, granted February 20, 1934, to James L. Finch.

The space paths in both sections of tube 96 are rendered normally conductive by connecting a battery H and a resistor 99 in circuit between the anodes and ground. The cathode potentials are independently `controllable by the 'potential drop in each :of Athe two cathode resistors 91 and 98. Hence the resultant anode potential variations are reflected in variations of lpotential drop in resistor 99, the latter constituting aresistive coupling means for the locking circuit Il) l.

The output from `the locking circuit `lill is communicated to a telegraph recorder 59 in the same manner as indicated in Fig, 2. In other respects, the operation of the circuit Varrangement of Fig. 6 will be readily understood in View of the foregoing description.

Various other modifications of my invention may be made by those skilled in the art in view of the foregoing description, but will be understood to be comprehended within the scope of the invention as claimed.

I claim:

1. In a signaling system, a keying device arranged to transmit message code signals the marking and spacing elements of which are of dot unit length and multiples thereof, a second keying device arranged to produce a complex repeatin-g pattern of marking and spacing elements having a dot unit length which is an even number fraction of the first said dot unit length, means for synchronously combining the effects of the two said keying devices to produce an enoiphered signatrain wherein discontinuities are introduced into .the marking elements of said message code signals, receiving apparatus responsive to said enciphered signal train, a time delay device associated with -said receiving apparatus and arranged to elongate the received marking elements of said enciphered signal train in such manner as to cancel said discontinuities, and means for combining the eiiects of said time delay device with the received train of enciphered signals in such manner that the intelligence of said message code signals is restored.

2. In a code signal transmitting system employing marking and spacing code elements which are of dot unit length and multiplesv of that length, the method of enciphering said code elements which includes periodically mutilating certain but not all of the marking elements of said signals by interrupting their continuity during time intervals which represent an even fraction of the time interval of a dot code element.

3. In a code signal receiving system employing marking and spacing code elements which upon reception are characterized by cryptic discontinuities in their marking elements of dot unit length and multiples of that length, the method of deciphering said code elements to restore their message significance which comprises generating control pulses at an even harmonic frequency with respect to the dot unit frequency of the message signals, producing fill-in potentials during limited time intervals which commence with said control pulses and are CoeXtensive with said cryptic discontinuities, and combining the effects of said fill-in potentials with those 0f the received code elements to produce a train of message signals.

4. The method according to claim 3 and including the step of synchronizing said control pulses with the steep wave fronts ofthe received marking code elements.

5. An enciphering system comprising a cryptic code element keying device arranged to deliver successive discrete trains of periodic pulses, a message keying device arranged to deliver marking and spacing signals of dot unit length and multiples thereof, the dot frequency of the message keying device being sub-harmonically related to that of the cryptic code element keying device, means for combining the eirects of the two said keying devices in such manner that a selected portion of the marking elements of the message signals are replaced by discrete cryptic code elements, and means for transmitting an enciphered train of signals composed in part of said cryptic code elements and composed in part of unmutilated message code elements.

6. An enciphering system according to claim and including a twin diode discharge tube in the means for combining the effects of the two said keying devices, said tube having a common output circuit connected to its two anodes, independent resistors connected between each of its cathodes and ground, a direct current source having its negative terminal grounded and its positive terminal connected to said common output circuit, and means controlled by each of the keying devices for applying positive potentials to the respective cathodes in said tube thereby to interrupt the emission of electrons from either of said cathodes alone or both together.

7. A system for enciphering code signals comprising a keying device for composing marking and spacing elements of dot unit length and multiples thereof representing message characters, a second keying device having electronic oscillation generating means for producing an arbitrary series of dot and dash symbols at a rate harmonically related to the dot frequency of the message signals, and electronic means for combining the eects of the two said keying devices.

8. A system for deciphering a signal train composed of marking and spacing elements the dot unit frequency of which bears a harmonic relation to the dot unit frequency of certain message signals into which said train is to be resolved, said system comprising electronic oscillation generating means for producing a periodic train of pulses, electronic means controlled by said pulses for developing a rectangular wave, a twin diode discharge tube for combining the effects of said signal train as received with the eects of said rectangular Wave, and means responsive to the operation of said tube for recording said message signals.

9. A system in accordance with claim 8 and including means for synchronizing said' oscillation generating means with the received signal train.

10. In an enciphering and deciphering system employing a signal train composed of marking and spacing elements wherein the dot signal is of unit length duration and other elements are an integral multiple of said unit length, and wherein the basic dot unit length of a message signal train is also an integral multiple of said unit length, the method of rendering signals unintelligible during transmission and of restoring the original intelligence thereof upon reception, which comprises combining said message train with an arbitrarily composed series of spacing elements of the rst said unit length, the intervening marking elements of said series being partly of the first said unit length and partly of an integral multiple of that length, said spacing elements being eiective to disintegrate the coincident marking elements of the message train, and restoring the marking elements of the message train by lling in the spacing gaps produced by such disintegration.

l1. In a code signal transmitting system employing marking and spacing code elements which are of dot unit length and multiples of that length, the method of enciphering said code elements which includes mutilating all of those marking code elements which are of multiple dot unit length and only certain ones but not all of those marking code elements which are of dot unit length by interrupting their continuity dur ing time intervals which represent substantially an even fraction of the time interval of a dot code element.

WARREN H. BLISS.

REFERENCES CITED The following references are of record in the le of this patent:

UNITED STATES PATENTS Number Name Date 2,266,509 Percival et al. Dec. 16, 1941 2,384,379 Ingram s- Sept. 4, 1945 FOREIGN PATENTS Number Country Date 552,301 Great Britain Mar. 31, 1943 

